My take on Earth Hour
March 29th, 2009
So I know that there have been many posts done on this, so I’m going to try to keep this brief. I don’t flatter myself in thinking that I have a lot of original thought on this one!
I celebrated Earth Hour last night by accidentally falling asleep. I was planning to spend the nice, dark time in thought about my life and the life of those around me. To think about what I do each day that leaves a damaging mark on this planet. Instead I got about a 45 minute nap. That being said, I didn’t get a lot of uninterrupted thought in, but I did enough to realize how futile something like Earth Hour is without the much needed follow up.
I’m sure there were plenty of parents around the world using that hour yesterday as a teaching moment for their children and plenty of people using that hour as a cleansing moment to launch their new greener lifestyle. But I also know that there were plenty of people doing it for the feel good factor. Members of my family are definitely on that list. They turned off the lights and enjoyed an unplugged hour. They did it because they felt it was something they should do, something global they should participate in, but then they turned the lights back on and went back to their lives. They were not changed in any way by those beautiful low-tech moments.
I also noticed a decal up at a McDonald’s I walked past on friday. It was them talking about how they will be celebrating earth hour by shutting down for that hour. I mean, I guess this is a nice gesture, but how does that even fit at McDonald’s? It gives them good publicity I imagine, but in the grand scheme of things what does it mean? As far as a I can discern, nothing.
With all of these negative thoughts in my head, I hope all the supporters of earth hour can see why my feelings are pretty lukewarm on the subject. Clearly its a great global moment, but at 9:31 last night, when the lights turned back on, what had changed? And how do those of us who are trying to make a difference on this front use that hour as a springboard for change? I certainly don’t know.
While its amazing that we, as a global community, were able to have yesterday, I’m not sure that it was worth the trouble and the hype. How many people participating in earth hour making a pledge to have earth hour once a month, or once a week, or once a day for the rest of this year? Would that have made a difference? I don’t know, but I think that we can all do better than earth hour once a year and I think we are going to have to.
I am glad for those parents who used it as a teaching moment and for those people who used it as a springboard for being more green, but I can’t help but ask what next?
I am sorry for the dark tone of this entry. I know I’m usually a bit more light-hearted when it comes to this stuff, but last night just kinda brought home the state of the world we live in to me. I was wanting to be inspired, but I just couldn’t muster those feelings.